Affiliate Disclaimer: The editors at Sleepy Globetrotter handpick all recommendations. If you make a purchase or book a hotel through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you.
If you’re wondering where to stay on São Jorge Island, Azores, let me save you some scrolling. Quinta da Magnólia AR is as close to perfect as you’re going to get. It’s quiet, comfortable, and surrounded by scenery so beautiful it should come with a warning: “May cause extreme relaxation.”
São Jorge Island isn’t your run-of-the-mill getaway. Known for its towering cliffs, jaw-dropping fajãs (those flat, coastal terraces carved by nature), and a cheese so good it’s practically a local celebrity, this island offers an unhurried, authentic charm.
But after you’ve explored its dramatic landscapes and feasted on queijo São Jorge, where do you crash for the night?
Here are three stellar options to keep you cozy, charmed, and maybe just a little spoiled.
Quinta da Magnólia AR
Quinta da Magnólia AR is the kind of place where the line between luxury and homely charm blurs beautifully. Nestled in Urzelina, it boasts private pools that practically beg you to dive in after a long day of adventuring. Rooms are thoughtfully designed, with plush seating areas, flat-screen TVs, and walk-in showers that make you reconsider your bathroom at home. And let’s not forget those bathrobes—because nothing says “vacation” like lounging in a bathrobe you didn’t have to buy.
Breakfast here is an experience in itself, featuring everything from fluffy pancakes to local cheeses that pair beautifully with your morning coffee. And when you’re ready to explore, the car rental service makes it easy to discover the island’s hidden gems. Bonus points for being a mere 4 km from São Jorge Airport—because no one likes a long trek after a flight. Click to view the images >>
Quinta dos Mistérios – Turismo de Habitação
If São Jorge’s charm had a physical address, it might just be Quinta dos Mistérios in Fajã de Santo Amaro. This stunning property feels like stepping into a more serene version of life, with a lush garden and an inviting year-round outdoor pool that whispers, “stay just a little longer.” The rooms vary in size and style, with some offering private entrances and balconies where you can sip wine as the ocean hums in the background.
Mornings here are a treat, with a breakfast spread featuring local specialties, fresh fruit, and enough warm dishes to make you question if it’s acceptable to have seconds (it is). The proximity to São Jorge Airport means your journey here is hassle-free, but the peaceful surroundings will make you forget airports even exist. Click to view the images >>
Casa d’Avó Guesthouse and Apartment
Casa d’Avó Guesthouse in Urzelina is a cozy farm stay that’s all about the views—mountains on one side, the sparkling sea on the other. The property balances rustic charm with modern comforts, offering private entrances for all rooms and thoughtful touches like free toiletries and satellite TVs. There’s even an outdoor fireplace, perfect for those cooler evenings when you want to trade stories with fellow travelers under the stars.
This guesthouse takes relaxation to another level, with sun terraces that make for great napping spots and easy access to hiking and cycling trails if you’re feeling energetic. And if water sports are your thing, you’re in luck—this spot has facilities for that, too. Only 5 km from the airport, it’s the perfect blend of convenience and escapism. Click to view the images >>
Final Words
São Jorge Island is all about natural beauty and simple pleasures, and these three accommodations reflect that perfectly.
They’re not the cheapest options on the island, but let’s be honest—comfort, charm, and a great breakfast are worth the extra euros.
Whether you’re diving into a private pool, sipping wine on a balcony, or swapping tales by an outdoor fire, these spots offer a slice of São Jorge’s magic. You’ll leave with memories, maybe a tan, and definitely a suitcase that smells like cheese (don’t worry, that’s a good thing).