Affiliate Disclaimer: The editors at Sleepy Globetrotter handpick all recommendations. If you make a purchase or book a hotel through our links, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you.
If you’re trying to figure out where to stay in Isla Mujeres, The Mermaid and The Pearl Boutique Hotel offers a fantastic mix of comfort, affordability, and charm. You’ll get the island life with a little extra luxury. No need for a second mortgage here!
So, you’ve decided on Isla Mujeres—good choice. Now, the real question: where to stay? After a bit of digging through the endless options, I’ve found three spots that genuinely stand out.
These aren’t your typical cookie-cutter hotels. Instead, they offer character, charm, and just enough personality to make your stay memorable.
No overpriced minibar snacks here—just great places that give you more than just a bed. If you’re after somewhere unique and fun, these are my top picks for where to stay.
The Mermaid and The Pearl Boutique Hotel
Let’s get one thing straight: this place is not your average hotel. The Mermaid and The Pearl feels more like someone’s meticulously curated guesthouse.
You’ll find everything here that’s been carefully thought through, from the breakfast (pancakes and local specialties that taste like they were made by your mum) to the rooftop pool that you’ll never want to leave. The rooms are simple yet elegant, with a sprinkle of island charm.
What I love about it? The fact that it’s perfectly positioned. A few steps from Norte Beach and yet far enough from the tourist crowds. It’s a peaceful haven but still close to everything you want to experience. And if you fancy a bit of adventure, grab one of their bikes and explore the island like a local. Click to view the images >>
Casa Azul Maya
If you want a bit more space and flexibility without forgoing comfort, Casa Azul Maya is where it’s at.
This place feels like it was designed for people who enjoy their privacy but don’t want to miss out on modern conveniences. The rooms have all the tech you need, from flat-screen TVs to coffee machines (because who can function without caffeine in the morning?). The kitchenette means you can cook your own meals if you get tired of the endless tacos.
What makes this place special? It’s the ability to have your own space while being close to the action. Plus, it’s just a short stroll to the beach, so you can work off all those snacks you ate while watching the flat-screen. Click to view the images >>
Mayan Monkey Isla Mujeres – Adults Only
Now, this one is for those who want the island vibes but with a little more “grown-up” charm.
Mayan Monkey Isla Mujeres is a fantastic adults-only hotel where you can actually relax without the sound of children splashing around. The rooms are modern and slick, and some even come with a terrace where you can sip a cocktail while watching the waves crash. The beach area is like your own private slice of paradise, and the pool just begs you to dip your toes in.
Here’s what I love: It’s got that perfect mix of relaxation and fun. You can spend the day chilling out by the pool, go for a bike ride, or even join in on some evening entertainment. And when you’re hungry, the restaurant does an excellent job of keeping you fueled for whatever the day throws at you. Click to view the images >>
Final Words
Okay, let’s wrap this up. These aren’t the cheapest hotels on Isla Mujeres, but that’s because they’ve got something more than just a place to sleep.
These are the kind of places where you can genuinely relax, have fun, and actually feel like you’re part of the island—not just a tourist. It’s worth spending a little extra for a stay that won’t leave you regretting your decision at 3 a.m. when the air conditioning breaks. Trust me.